- Scotusblog docket entries, here.
- Susan C. Morse, Argument preview: What limits tax law obstruction-of-justice charges? (Scotusblog 11/28/17), here.
- Oral Argument (recorded audio only; when it is available), here. (The Supreme Court website says here that oral argument voice recordings are available by the end of the week of the oral argument.)
- Transcripts of oral argument, here. (Available now.)
Marinello argues that there is no limiting principle to the corruptly mens rea requirement, so that it is appropriate to constrict the scope of § 7212(a) to conduct intended to obstruct a pending investigation. That is a simplified version of the argument as I understand it. The Government argues in its brief, here, as follows.
From Summary of the Argument:
II.
* * * *
C. A defendant’s endeavor does not violate Section 7212(a) unless he acts “corruptly” and intends to obstruct the due administration of the tax code. Those mens rea requirements ensure that a defendant is aware that his obstructive acts are directed at the IRS’s administration of the tax code, that he intends to obstruct those functions, and that he does so with the specific intent of obtaining a benefit or advantage that he knows to be illegal. The mens rea elements of Section 7212(a) readily distinguish purposeful tax violators from those who lack a culpable intent to obstruct and ensure that the provision is not a trap for the unwary.From the Argument (pp. 18-21):