FBAR Willful Penalty (with Collection Suit) after OVDP Drop Opt-Out (9/1/22)

The Government filed an FBAR collection suit in United States v. Leeds (Idaho No. 22-cv-00379-BLW), see TaxNotes copy of complaint here.  The defendant “is the surviving spouse of Richard Leeds, named in her capacity as a potential successor-in-interest to the Estate of Richard Leeds “(Estate”) and/or as a potential personal representative or administrator of the Estate and/or distributee of the Estate.”)

The complaint is about what one would expect in an FBAR collection suit, with slight variances in facts.  However, the following caught my attention:

36. In December of 2014 Mr. Leeds applied to participate in the IRS's Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program and was initially accepted.

* * * *

39. In April 2018 Mr. Leeds opted out of the OVDP and an IRS examination commenced.

The IRS then proposed a willful FBAR penalty, eventually resulting in this collection suit to collect the penalty.

That is all I know about the facts, but I have these questions, with some speculation as to answers:

1. Since Mr. Leeds knew what the OVDP cost would be going into the program, why would he opt out?  I can only speculate that he wanted to get the benefit of the criminal prosecution protection OVDP offered.  Otherwise, going into OVDP knowing the civil cost would be unacceptable makes no sense.

2. In any event, why would someone with his facts (from the complaint) opt-out of OVDP after he had disclosed his behavior by the OVDP filing?  I can’t even speculate about that other than perhaps he had some vague hope that the IRS would drop the ball in his case.  Remember, that if he had a good nonwillful story, he could have made a Streamlined Filing; I assume he entered OVDP because he (or his counsel) thought he did not have a good nonwillful story.